Test the theory

5.1 Explain the troubleshooting methodology

📘CompTIA Network+ (N10-009)

---

After you establish a theory of probable cause (the previous step in the troubleshooting process), the next step is to test that theory. This is a critical step because it helps you confirm whether your guess about the problem is correct before implementing a full solution.

What “Test the Theory” Means

1. Definition:
   Testing the theory means checking if your suspected cause is actually responsible for the problem. You are validating your assumption before making major changes to the system.
2. Purpose:
   • Prevents unnecessary changes that might create more problems.
   • Helps narrow down the actual issue quickly.
   • Ensures a methodical approach instead of guessing.

---

Steps to Test the Theory

1. Review the Theory Carefully
   • Look at the probable cause you identified.
   • Make sure your theory makes sense with the symptoms you observed.
   • Example: If users cannot access a shared network folder, your theory might be: “The permissions on the folder were recently changed and are blocking access.”
2. Perform a Controlled Test
   • Test your theory in a small, controlled way before fully implementing a solution.
   • Example: Try accessing the folder as an admin or check permissions on a test user account.
3. Observe the Results
   • Does the controlled test confirm your theory?
   • Example: If the test account can access the folder when permissions are corrected, your theory is likely correct. If not, your theory might be wrong, and you need to re-evaluate.
4. Document What You Learn
   • Keep a record of what you tested, what worked, and what didn’t.
   • Example: Document the original folder permissions, the test you ran, and the outcome.

---

Important Points to Remember

• Start small: Never make major network changes before confirming your theory.
• One change at a time: Changing multiple things at once can confuse the results.
• Keep it reversible: Make sure any test can be undone without affecting other systems.
• Re-evaluate if necessary: If the test fails, go back and form a new theory and test again.

---

Real IT Examples

Here are some IT-focused examples for the exam:

1. Network Connectivity Issue:
   • Symptom: A workstation cannot connect to the internet.
   • Theory: The workstation is assigned a wrong IP address.
   • Test: Check the IP configuration with ipconfig or ping the gateway.
   • Outcome: If the ping fails and IP is wrong, the theory is correct.
2. Slow Application Performance:
   • Symptom: Users complain a web application is slow.
   • Theory: The server is overloaded.
   • Test: Check CPU and memory usage on the server.
   • Outcome: High usage confirms the theory. You can then take steps to optimize or upgrade the server.
3. Email Delivery Problems:
   • Symptom: Emails are not reaching users.
   • Theory: The email server’s SMTP service is down.
   • Test: Use telnet to connect to the SMTP port or check server logs.
   • Outcome: If the connection fails, your theory is correct.

---

Exam Tips for This Section

• Understand the difference between theory and solution. The theory is the suspected cause; the solution is how you fix it.
• You may get scenario questions where you have to pick the correct next step after forming a theory—always select “test the theory” before implementing a fix.
• Focus on controlled, reversible testing in all examples. CompTIA likes to test your understanding of safe troubleshooting practices.

---

✅ Summary in Simple Terms:

1. Make a guess about the problem (theory).
2. Test that guess carefully in a controlled way.
3. Observe the results.
4. If correct, move to implement a solution. If not, go back and make a new theory.