1.6 Compare and contrast network topologies, architectures, and types
📘CompTIA Network+ (N10-009)
Star Topology / Hub-and-Spoke Topology
Definition
A star topology is a network design where all devices (computers, printers, servers, etc.) are connected to a central device called a hub, switch, or router.
- In IT terms, the hub or switch acts as a central point for managing network traffic.
- Data from one device always travels through the central device to reach other devices.
A hub-and-spoke topology is basically a wide-area network (WAN) version of a star.
- Here, multiple branch offices (spokes) connect to a central office (hub).
- The central hub manages traffic between all the spokes.
Structure / Diagram (Conceptually)
Device A
|
Device B
|
Central Hub/Switch/Router
|
Device C
|
Device D
For hub-and-spoke:
Branch 1
|
Branch 2
|
Central Hub Office
|
Branch 3
Key Features
- Centralized Management
- All devices connect to one central device.
- Easy to monitor and control network traffic from the hub or switch.
- Simple to Add or Remove Devices
- Adding a new computer only requires a connection to the central device.
- Removing a device doesn’t affect the rest of the network.
- Common Devices Used
- Switch – Most common today; can forward data only to the intended device (more efficient than a hub).
- Hub – Older technology; sends data to all devices (less efficient).
- Router – Can act as a hub in WAN scenarios.
- Fault Isolation
- If one device fails, the rest of the network keeps working.
- If the central device fails, the whole network goes down.
- Performance
- Good performance for smaller networks.
- Switches can reduce collisions using full-duplex communication.
- Performance may degrade if the hub is overloaded.
Advantages
- Easy to manage and troubleshoot because all connections converge at a central point.
- Flexible to expand; just plug in more devices.
- Fault isolation is easier — problem in one device doesn’t affect others.
- Compatible with modern networking hardware like Ethernet switches and routers.
Disadvantages
- Single point of failure: If the central hub or switch fails, the whole network fails.
- More cabling required because each device needs its own cable to the hub.
- Cost can be higher for large networks due to cabling and the central device.
Use in IT Environments
- LAN (Local Area Network)
- Offices often use a star topology.
- Example: Computers and printers in a floor connect to a central Ethernet switch.
- WAN (Wide Area Network) – Hub-and-Spoke
- Branch offices connect to the main data center via a router (hub).
- Central office manages all communication, such as email, file access, or VPN connections.
- Data Centers
- Core switches act as hubs connecting multiple servers.
- Provides high control over traffic flow between servers.
- VPN Connections
- A central VPN server (hub) allows remote users (spokes) to securely connect to company resources.
Exam Tips
- Remember the “central device” concept: All data goes through the hub/switch/router.
- Fault tolerance: One device failing is okay; central device failing is critical.
- Star = LAN; Hub-and-Spoke = WAN version of Star.
- Know the difference between hub and switch: hub sends to all, switch sends to intended device only.
- Common question: “Which topology isolates faults better?” → Star is preferred over bus.
✅ Quick Summary Table
| Feature | Star Topology | Hub-and-Spoke Topology |
|---|---|---|
| Central Device | Hub/Switch/Router | Central Hub/Router |
| Device Failure Impact | Only failed device affected | Only failed branch affected; hub failure affects all |
| Scalability | Easy | Easy, but depends on hub capacity |
| Common Use | LAN | WAN (branch offices) |
| Cabling | Requires individual cables | Requires connection to central hub |
